Best Eyeliner Pencil for Mature Eyes: Top Picks for a Youthful Glow

Eyeliner is an essential makeup item that can define and enhance the appearance of the eyes. Finding the right eyeliner pencil can be especially important for mature eyes. As we age, the skin around the eyes can become more delicate and prone to wrinkles.

** I may earn a commission when you purchase through a link on this page. **

A good eyeliner for mature eyes should glide on smoothly, without tugging or pulling the delicate skin. It should also stay put throughout the day without smudging or settling into fine lines.

When looking for the best eyeliner pencil for mature eyes, it’s crucial to consider the formula’s consistency and ingredients. A pencil with a creamy texture that allows for a smooth application is ideal. It should also be long-lasting to avoid frequent touch-ups.

eyeliner for mature ladies

Additionally, some eyeliners contain moisturizing ingredients like Vitamin E, which can be beneficial for maintaining the skin’s health around the eyes.

The application method is also an important consideration. A retractable pencil can be more convenient as it doesn’t require sharpening and can therefore be gentler on the skin. On the other hand, traditional wooden pencils offer a finer point for a more precise line, which might be preferred by some users.

Ultimately, the goal is to find a product that will highlight your eyes without causing irritation or emphasizing fine lines and wrinkles.

Top Eyeliner Pencils for Mature Eyes

I have carefully selected these eyeliner pencils because they play a crucial role in enhancing the beauty of mature eyes. Their formulations are gentle, ensuring easy application without tugging on the delicate skin. Plus, they boast long-lasting wear and a variety of textures to suit every preference. Whether you prefer a classic look or something more dramatic, there’s an option here for everyone. Let’s take a look at which ones stood out!

L’Oreal Paris Age Perfect Eyeliner

L'Oreal Paris Age Perfect Satin Glide Eyeliner product image
View on Amazon


  • Glides on smoothly without tugging
  • Waterproof and doesn’t migrate throughout the day
  • Features an ergonomic grip for precise application


  • The tip can break off if too much pressure is applied
  • May not last as long during hot, sweaty days
  • Color intensity might be too subtle for some preferences

I recommend this eyeliner for those who want a gentle, smudge-resistant option that’s specifically designed for mature skin.

L'Oreal Paris Age Perfect Satin Glide Eyeliner with Mineral Pigments, Brown

The L’Oreal Paris Age Perfect Satin Glide Eyeliner is a real game-changer for my daily makeup routine. The gentle formula doesn’t irritate my sensitive eyes, and I love how it applies evenly without any dragging. It’s refreshing to have an eyeliner that cooperates with my mature skin while enhancing my eyes with a natural look.

The staying power of this waterproof eyeliner has truly impressed me. I can go about my day with confidence, knowing that it won’t smudge or end up making unintended raccoon eyes. Additionally, the ergonomic rubber grip makes it so much easier to apply a precise line, which I find invaluable as my hand isn’t as steady as it used to be.

While the brown shade complements my features with a soft, natural definition, I’ve noticed it may not be intense enough for someone who prefers a more dramatic look. The pencil tip is a bit fragile, and on my first use, I applied too much pressure, causing it to snap. Now that I’ve adjusted how I handle it, breakage hasn’t been an issue. Despite these minor drawbacks, I am pleased with the overall performance and feel it’s a smart staple for anyone with mature skin seeking a reliable eyeliner.

PrimeEyes Glide by PRIME PROMETICS

PrimeEyes Glide eyeliner product photo
View on Amazon


  • Glides on with ease, thanks to the creamy gel texture.
  • Resists smudging and stays intact even on my watery eye days.
  • Includes a convenient smudger for softening lines and a sharpener to keep the tip precise.


  • The product quantity seemed less than expected for the price.
  • Required touch-ups after a few hours, despite the long-stay claim.
  • Limited color selection narrows creative expression.

I found the smooth application and wearability of PrimeEyes Glide ideal for creating a variety of eyeliner looks that last throughout the day.

PRIME PROMETICS PrimeEyes Glide Eyeliner for Mature Women – Waterproof, Long-Stay and Mess-Proof – Gel Cream Texture, Discreet Sharpener and Effective Smudger (Black)

Upon twisting up the PrimeEyes Glide eyeliner, the soft, creamy texture surprised me. This allowed for a smooth and precise line without any tugging on my delicate eyelid skin. As someone who occasionally struggles with smudgy eyeliners, I appreciated how it set quickly and didn’t transfer to my crease or under-eye area, a testament to its smudge-proof feature.

Through daily wear, one highlight was how the eyeliner maintained a rich, pigmented color from morning to sunset. It’s a boon for my sensitive eyes that often wrestle with irritation from other eyeliners – no such issues here. My eyes remained comfortable, and I didn’t have to fret over potential smears or streaks after an emotional movie or battling the spring breeze.

While the PrimeEyes Glide ticks many boxes, I must admit the product length inside the pencil was a tad underwhelming considering its cost. For the longevity angle, I anticipated not needing any touch-ups all day, but found myself reaching for the pencil again come afternoon.

While the colors available are lovely and cover basic needs, expanding the range could inspire more diverse and creative looks. Nonetheless, for everyday wear, this eyeliner proves to be a reliable companion, staying mostly faithful to its description.

Revlon ColorStay Eyeliner

Revlon ColorStay Eyeliner product image
View on Amazon


  • Resists smudging and lives up to its long-wearing claim
  • The inclusion of a sharpener ensures precision with every use
  • Built-in smudger allows for versatile styling, from sharp lines to a smoky eye


  • A bit of a learning curve for those new to pencil eyeliners
  • Not the ideal choice for those preferring a dewy or glossy finish
  • Limited color selection for creative makeup enthusiasts

If you’re seeking an eyeliner that can take you from morning coffee to evening nightcap without a smudge in sight, this is your go-to pencil.

Revlon Pencil Eyeliner, Gifts for Women, Stocking Stuffers, ColorStay Eye Makeup with Built-in Sharpener, Waterproof, Smudge-proof, Longwearing with Ultra-Fine Tip, 201 Black, 0.01 oz

From my recent experience using the Revlon ColorStay Eyeliner, I’m impressed by its resilience. My day often begins with an early morning routine and doesn’t slow down until late at night. This eyeliner has consistently stayed put without the need for touch-ups, which speaks volumes about its formula.

The pencil’s design facilitates ease of use. The sharpener is a lifesaver. It’s incredibly convenient for maintaining a crisp line, while the attached smudger is perfect for those days when I want a softer, more blended look. Transitioning from a day at the office to an evening look is a breeze with this tool.

What truly sets this eyeliner apart is how it manages to cater to the delicate eye area, especially for mature skin. It does not tug or pull; instead, it glides on effortlessly, depositing just the right amount of color and depth. Admittedly, the matte finish and hue selection are not the most diverse, but for everyday wear, it hits all the right notes. The shades available are classic and, frankly, you can’t go wrong with a timelessly defined eye.

E.l.f. No Budge Eyeliner

e.l.f. No Budge Eyeliner product image
View on Amazon


  • Glides on effortlessly, preventing any tugging on the delicate eyelid area
  • Remarkably long-lasting, keeping my eyes defined from morning till evening
  • Vegan and cruelty-free, aligning with my ethical beauty standards


  • Removal requires a bit more effort, ideally with an oil-based makeup remover
  • May not withstand very wet conditions without some smudging
  • The integrated sharpener could be better designed for a finer tip

After trying this eyeliner, I think it’s a fantastic choice for anyone seeking a budget-friendly option that truly delivers on longevity and pigmentation.

e.l.f., No Budge Retractable Eyeliner, Creamy, Ultra-Pigmented, Long Lasting, Enhances, Defines, Intensifies, Boldens, Grey, All-Day Wear, 0.008 Oz

When I first applied the e.l.f. No Budge Eyeliner, I noticed immediately how creamy the texture was. There was no skipping or dragging, which I’ve experienced with other liners, making it gentle for my mature eyes.

The rich grey color intensified my eyes with just a single stroke, creating a sophisticated look without being overpowering.

Throughout the day, the eyeliner stayed put without migrating into the creases or corners of my eyes – a crucial aspect for any eyeliner aimed at those with more mature skin. Its durability impressed me, especially considering the very reasonable price point.

I found that this waterproof formula does need a good oil-based makeup remover for a clean swipe-off, which isn’t a dealbreaker but worth noting. With repeated use, the blunt tip could make thin lines trickier to achieve. However, the overall performance makes the e.l.f. No Budge Eyeliner is an excellent staple in my makeup routine.

L’Oreal Paris Infallible Eyeliner

L'Oreal Paris Infallible Eyeliner product image
View on Amazon


  • The gel formula means it glides on without dragging delicate skin.
  • Its 36-hour staying power makes constant touch-ups a thing of the past.
  • Waterproof capabilities allow for confidence in any weather.


  • May require a bit of practice to achieve super-precise lines.
  • Some users might find the color variety lacking.
  • The blending tip could be too soft for those who prefer a sharper line.

If you’re looking for an eyeliner that can keep up with long days and still look freshly applied, this one might become your new go-to.

L'Oreal Paris Infallible Grip Mechanical Gel Eyeliner Pencil, Smudge-Resistant, Waterproof Eye Makeup with Up to 36HR Wear, Brown Denim, 0.01 Oz

I recently got my hands on the L’Oreal Paris Infallible Eyeliner, and I was genuinely impressed by its performance.

The formula is indeed long-wearing; it stood firmly by me through a hectic day without the need for any touch-ups.

The ease with which it applied took me by surprise – no tugging or skipping, just smooth, consistent color that made my eyes pop.

I experimented with the included blending tip and found it beneficial for creating a smudged, smokey eye effect effortlessly. The color didn’t fade or flake away, which is a major bonus for someone like me who values a makeup look that lasts all day.

The only quirk I experienced was achieving the finesse required for an ultra-thin line. It took me a couple of tries, but once I got the hang of it, the results were stunning. For anyone with mature eyes or those who struggle with fine lines, this pencil could be a real game-changer.

Julep Longwear Eyeliner

Julep Longwear Eyeliner product image
View on Amazon


  • Glides on with ease, with no pulling or tugging involved.
  • Remarkably long-wearing, staying put for over 10 hours.
  • Rich brown hue that complements a plethora of skin tones.


  • Requires sharpening, which might lead to product wastage.
  • Might smudge under very warm or moist conditions.
  • The color payoff may be less vibrant on watery eyes.

I believe the Julep Longwear Eyeliner is a treasure for mature eyes, offering impressive staying power without tugging on delicate skin.

Julep When Pencil Met Gel Sharpenable Multi-Use Longwear Eyeliner Pencil - Rich Brown - Transfer-Proof - High Performance Liner

Using this eyeliner, I found its creamy texture stood out right away. There’s no dragging across the eyelid — a huge plus for anyone who dreads the stretching effect of firmer pencils on mature skin.

I appreciated the rich brown matte finish of the Julep eyeliner. It’s a sophisticated departure from harsh black liners and adds a soft but defined look to the eyes that’s just perfect for day-to-day wear.

Despite my long day, the liner didn’t stray into creases or fade away, a testament to its ten-hour claim. A quick swipe in the morning remained intact until I decided to take it off; it’s refreshingly reliable in that aspect.

Neutrogena Smokey Kohl

Neutrogena smokey kohl product image
View on Amazon


  • Glides on without tugging, perfect for delicate skin
  • Stays put all day, no need for touch-ups
  • Blendable when first applied, allowing for a customizable look


  • Might be too bold for those preferring a subtle line
  • Limited color selection may not suit everyone
  • Smudge-proof formula means you need to work quickly to blend

If you’re seeking a reliable eyeliner for mature eyes that delivers a bold, lasting look, this Neutrogena option is a standout choice.

Neutrogena Smokey Kohl Eyeliner with Antioxidant Vitamin E, Water-Resistant & Smooth-Gliding Eyeliner Makeup, Dark Brown, 0.014 oz

The moment I unsheathed this little beauty, its creamy texture impressed me; it didn’t pull or drag along my lid, which is crucial to avoid when your skin’s elasticity is not what it used to be.

With older eyes, the last thing you want is an eyeliner that’s unforgiving, so I found its smooth glide to be a significant plus.

Rich, robust color emerged as soon as it kissed my skin—a stark contrast to some pencils that force you to go over the same spot multiple times. I reveled in the initial flexibility that allowed me to smoke out the line for a sultry effect, though you must act fast before it sets.

Locking in for the day, this product’s staying power was admirable. I waded through my routine, braced for the dreaded raccoon eyes, but there was no budging or flaking. As someone who values time, not having to fret about my eye makeup is liberating.

Rimmel Scandaleyes Eyeliner

Rimmel Scandaleyes Waterproof Gel Pencil Eyeliner product image
View on Amazon


  • Rich coloration delivers dramatic eye definition.
  • Creamy texture ensures effortless application.
  • Resistant to smudging and the elements, perfect for long wear.


  • The pencil requires sharpening for precision.
  • Product quantity can feel limited.
  • May not be the easiest to remove due to its waterproof nature.

If you’re seeking enduring allure without the worry of midday smudges, Rimmel’s Scandaleyes Waterproof Gel Pencil Eyeliner is my go-to liner.

Rimmel London Scandaleyes Waterproof Gel Pencil Eyeliner, Long-Wearing, Ultra-Smooth, Smudge-Proof, 001, Black, 0.04oz

Ever on the lookout for an eyeliner that won’t let me down, I’ve found that this pencil holds up incredibly under the tests of daily life. It’s creamy enough that I don’t have to tug on my sensitive eye skin, yet it sets in place for hours on end, just as fresh as when I first draw it on.

I’ve worn the Scandaleyes liner to many events, even those where I know there might be tears of joy, and impressively, it remains steadfast. Plus, as someone with mature eyes, the avant-garde pigments add a vibrant charm that lasts from morning coffee to evening wind-down.

Coming from a brand that champions eye safety, I appreciate that it’s both dermatologist and ophthalmologist-tested. This takes a load off my mind, considering my eye sensitivity. When I’m ready to let go of my defined eyes, patience is the key since this liner plays hard to get with my makeup remover.

essence Stay & Play Gel Eyeliner

essence Stay & Play Gel Eyeliner product image
View on Amazon


  • Glides on effortlessly with a creamy texture
  • Maintains a smudge-proof appearance all-day
  • Offers a compassionate choice with its vegan and cruelty-free status


  • May require multiple layers for full pigment saturation
  • Limited to only 8 shades which might not satisfy all preferences
  • The formula can be too soft, potentially leading to quicker product depletion

If you’re looking for a budget-friendly eyeliner that can keep up with your day, essence Stay & Play Gel Eyeliner is the product for you.

essence | Stay & Play Gel Eyeliner | Super Soft Gel-like Texture | Waterproof & Longlasting | Vegan & Cruelty Free (Black Raven)

Upon trying this eyeliner, I was impressed by its creamy texture. Truly, it goes on super smoothly—no tugging at the delicate skin around the eyes.

The intense black of “Black Raven” is great for a classic look but what caught my attention was how well it held up through a hectic day. No raccoon eyes by evening, which is a win!

The Stay & Play range promises versatility with its colors. I had fun experimenting with the different hues, adding a pop to my usual makeup routine. I particularly like the ease with which each shade harmonizes with diverse eyeshadow looks, offering a seamless blend.

While it’s a steal, essence’s pencil might require a couple of passes for that jet-black look that I love. Even when building up the color, the liner didn’t feel heavy, nor did it flake—a common problem with many other kohl pencils. My sensitive eyes appreciated the considerate formulation, free from parabens and fragrance.

Using this eyeliner felt like a savvy choice: it didn’t break the bank, it served its purpose admirably, and the cruelty-free aspect made me feel good about the purchase. While it might not carry the prestige of luxury brands, it punches well above its weight class, delivering satisfying results for everyday wear.

Buying Guide

Key Features to Consider

Ingredients: When I look for an eyeliner pencil, I prioritize ones that contain gentle ingredients. My mature eyes appreciate pencils without harsh chemicals that can irritate them.

  • Hydrating elements like Vitamin E and oils
  • Non-irritating compounds for sensitive eyes

Texture: I need an eyeliner that glides on smoothly. A creamy texture is ideal to avoid tugging on delicate skin.

Performance Metrics

Pigmentation: For me, strong pigmentation means less layering and reduced eye strain.

  • Rich color payoff in a single-stroke

Longevity: My eyeliner must last all day without smudging or fading.

  • Water-resistant yet easy to remove

Application and Removal

Precision: A thin, precise tip is essential for intricate makeup looks.

  • Allows for fine lines without pressure

Ease of Removal: I appreciate an eyeliner that can be removed gently without aggressive rubbing.

  • Should come off smoothly with a simple eye makeup remover


Mechanism: A retractable pencil seems to work better for me than those needing constant sharpening.

  • No need for a sharpener
  • Less product waste

Frequently Asked Questions

In this section, I’m addressing common queries regarding the best eyeliner pencils for mature eyes. My focus is providing advice that helps enhance the beauty of older women with gentle, effective products tailored to their needs.

What are some eyeliner application tips for older women?

For older women, I suggest using a light hand and applying eyeliner with short, soft strokes. To avoid a harsh look, it’s better to blend the line slightly using a smudging tool or a brush. This creates a softer and more forgiving appearance.

How to choose the right eyeliner color for mature eyes?

I find that selecting a color that complements your natural eye color is essential. For a subtle look, brown tones often work well for all eye colors. For more definition, a deep gray or navy can enhance the eyes without the intensity of black, which may be too harsh for mature skin.

Which type of eyeliner is better for avoiding creasing on wrinkled eyelids?

I recommend using a gel or liquid eyeliner for its smooth application and ability to set quickly, minimizing the chance of creasing. Pencil liners can work too, as long as they are soft and creamy, avoiding tugging on the delicate eyelid skin.

Are there any drugstore eyeliners suitable for people over 50 with sensitive eyes?

Absolutely, I’ve discovered that many drugstore brands offer hypoallergenic eyeliners designed for sensitive eyes. Look for labels that indicate “dermatologist tested,” “hypoallergenic,” or “opthalmologist approved” to ensure they are gentle on the eyes.

What is the preferred type of eyeliner for women over 60?

For women over 60, I generally suggest a softer pencil or a gel liner. They tend to be easier to apply without pulling the skin and can be blended for a more natural look, which is usually more flattering as the eye area becomes more delicate with age.

Can you recommend eyeliners that won’t tug on mature skin during application?

Yes, I prefer to use eyeliners specifically labeled as “creamy,” “kohl,” or “buttery” in texture since they glide on effortlessly.

Brands that cater to mature skin often formulate their eyeliners to be highly pigmented yet silky to apply, reducing the need for excessive pressure.

Last update on 2024-04-13 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

FitFab50 is your go-to active lifestyle site for women and men over 50! Whether you're a gym rat, a weekend hiker, or just looking for advice on what to wear to a pool party , we've got you covered. Searching for compression shirts or running shorts? Explore our top-notch reviews on the latest workout gear. We're also on top of the newest, best swimsuits for women and men that don't skimp on comfort or fit. We also share practical exercise tips and advice, specially designed for you.